They're attached to a
black keypad on the dashboard and start flashing on the first day a
car payment is late. On the fourth day, after two more days of warning
lights, the car won't start.
"I would not undertake
buy-here/pay-here without this system," said Ray Williamson, president
of North Texas Motorcars, which sells about 50 vehicles a month and
installs boxes in each of them. "There's just too much risk."
The box from a Temecula
company – called a starter interrupt unit – is used mostly at used-car
dealerships that provide financing to customers with bad credit. But
other segments of the auto industry may adopt it, particularly if
consumers' credit ratings continue to decline.
"I can see this
coming," said Michael R. Linn, chief executive of the National
Independent Automobile Dealers Association, which is based in Texas
and represents 19,000 used-car dealers nationwide.
"The technology is
there. Look at something like General Motors' OnStar. It can already
open doors and notify emergency authorities, and all of that. It could
certainly shut a car down."
The On Time unit
Williamson uses is marketed by Temecula's Payment Protection Systems
and is one of three or four such systems available. Mike Simon,
president and chief executive, said On Time sales have increased 40
percent since 1999.
The company has begun
selling On Time units equipped with GPS that some mainstream used-car
dealers are installing on $20,000-plus luxury cars.
"Some people have the
income and assets to buy a Mercedes-Benz but still have credit
problems," Simon said.
"This takes a lot of
the risk out of it, just like on the lower end."
He believes the devices
could be used in the new cars as well.
"In the auto industry,
there are prime and subprime buyers in every segment," Simon said.
"Even though you qualify for a new Ford or an SUV, you might still be
subprime because of your credit history. You can put this in a vehicle
and probably get the buyer a lower interest rate."
Disabler devices have
been available for three years and are used at about 15 percent of the
tote-the-note used-car lots in the United States, officials estimate.
The customers typically
have damaged or no credit and pay interest rates up to 26 percent. The
vehicles often have 70,000 or more miles on them and cost $7,000 to
$10,000 – or roughly $70 to $100 a week.
Andrea Gooden, a nurse
at a geriatric-care facility in Dallas, has bought four cars with the
devices on them and says she accepts them. Gooden drives a 2002 Honda
Accord and is helping a daughter at the University of Houston with her
car payment.
"The deal was, I make the first payment
of the month and my daughter makes the second," said Gooden, 46, of
Mesquite, Texas. "It warned her when she didn't make the payment on
time, and when it got to four days, the car quit running. She learned
not to do that again."
Gooden said the system helped reduce
the interest rate on her car to 13.9 percent.
Note lots have long been the auto
industry's roughest segment. But without them, industry officials say,
many working-class people would have to rely on public transportation
to get to their jobs. About 35 percent of the nation's 54,000 used-car
dealers operate buy-here/pay-here lots and contend with default rates
as high as 40 percent.
Systems such as On Time permit dealers
to "drill down" even deeper with severely credit-damaged customers and
still have some assurance that their only collateral on the high-risk
loans – the vehicles – can be retrieved if the buyers default.
"Nearly every Saturday, we talk with
someone who has been to seven or eight different buy-here/pay-here
lots and were turned down at all of them," Williamson said.
"More people in this
country have bad credit than have good credit," said James Ziegler, a
retail auto consultant in Duluth, Ga. "If somebody didn't take a
chance on these people, they wouldn't be able to work."
Simon of On Time said
the systems dramatically reduce late payments.
"We have taken a 70
percent delinquency rate in the buy-here/pay-here business and
transformed it to a 96 percent on-time rate," he said. "Now some
mainstream finance companies are even saying, 'I'll finance these
cars.'"